Sunday, September 23, 2007

Coal policy advisory committee to keep options open for open-pit, shaft mining

The Daily Star, September 23, 2007

A 12-member coal policy advisory team held a review meeting yesterday following its visit to Barapukuria coalmine, Phulbari and Dighipara the day before. The team will advice the government on framing the national draft coal policy, according to sources at Barapukuria Coal Mine Company Ltd (BCMCL).

Mineral and Resources Department of Petrobangla formed the committee headed by Abdul Matin Patwari, former vice-chancellor of Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (BUET) to help it finalise a draft national coal policy. Other members of the committee are Prof Nazrul Islam, chairman of Bangladesh University Grants Commission (UGC); Maj. Gen. Ismail Faruk Chowdhury, defence representative; Prof Nurul Islam, director of Institute of Appropriate Technology (IAT); Prof Badrul Imam, head of geology department of Dhaka University; journalist Ataus Samad; Prof Mustafizur Rahman of Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD); Nazrul Islam, chief executive of Infrastructure Investment Facilitation Centre (IIFC); Mokbul Elahi, director Petrobangla; Golam Mostafa, former managing director of BCMCL and Shahdeen Malik, a Supreme Court lawyer.

The team at its meeting at BCMCL auditorium yesterday reviewed recommendations of different professionals and rights group, local members of the National Committee to Protect Oil, Gas, Mineral Resources, Power and Port and Citizen's Commission of Bangladesh Economic Association (BEA). The committee sources said it would not recommend discarding any particular mining method to keep options open for both open-pit and shaft coal mining in the country.

The committee, however, did not agree in principle to recommendations of the National Committee to Protect Oil, Gas and Mineral resources and the BEA, which urged the government not to keep provision for open-pit mining system in the draft coal policy. The groups said open-pit mining pollutes the environment, displaces thousands of people from their homesteads and destroys vast areas of fertile farmlands.

The advisory committee also shared view of the two groups that coal export should not be allowed to ensure energy security for future generations. “We should not recommend or ban any mining method in the policy as the method should be fixed on the basis of technical, social, environmental and economic aspects”, Patwari told the review meeting. “If it is found that after cost-benefit analysis, open-pit mining is not viable, it is natural that no one will want to go for that (open-pit mining),” Patwari told the meeting. Other team members present at the meeting also shared Patwari's view, meeting sources said.

Basing on projected future coal requirement for power generation, Patwari said, if Bangladesh adopts only underground mining system, the extracted coal would be fully consumed even before 2025 while the government wants to ensure energy security for 50 years.

As per estimate, around 235 million tonnes of coal can be extracted through underground mining from four coalfields that have a total reserve of around 1,168 million tonnes. On the other hand, around 1,050 tonnes of coal can be extracted by open-pit mining.

Prof Badrul Imam, however, told the meeting that even if open-pit mining method is allowed in the country, it would not be possible to operate more than one open-pit mines as country's coal reserve is concentrated in only two districts.

The team left Dinajpur for Dhaka in the afternoon. Earlier they visited Dighipara under Nawabganj upazila in Dinajpur.

Friday, September 21, 2007

Coal Policy: Govt body to visit mine, coal rich areas today

The Daily Star, September 21, 2007

The committee tasked with finalising a coal policy for the country will be visiting today Barapukuria coal mine, Phulbari, Khalashpir, Dighipara and a few other areas that are rich with coal deposits. The members of the committee, accompanied by the energy secretary, will talk with the officials of Barapukuria Coal Mining Company as well as with the locals of Phulbari, including the ones who have been opposing the coal-mining proposal of Asia Energy, said sources.

On the way, the committee will visit the Dighipara and Khalashpir coal zones, the sources added. The committee also intends to visit and survey the area of Jamalganj -- the country's biggest coal deposit -- where no visible surface marking is available.

Furthermore, the committee that was formed in June has decided to send two of its members -- Prof Nurul Islam from Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (Buet) and Prof Badrul Imam from Geology Department of Dhaka University -- to the upcoming Saarc coal conference to be held in Kolkata in mid-October.

The committee recently resolved a vital debate on the mining method in the draft of national coal policy. While one group of people had been putting pressure on banning the open-pit method of mining in Bangladesh, the other group wanted all mining option to be open for particular mining proposals.

The committee decided that the policy would not restrict any mining method since it depends on technical issues such as geology or hydrology etc. and the government should have the discretionary authority to approve a mining method against each mining proposal.

The committee headed by Prof Abdul Matin Patwari, former vice chancellor of Buet, was formed as the sixth draft version of the national coal policy drew a lot of criticism for being anti-investment and self-contradictory.

The finalisation of the national coal policy is seen as a crucial document for the future of the existing deals with Asia Energy or Hosaf as well as for other offers that are pending government approval.

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Two coal committee members to attend SAARC coal conference

NewAge, Dhaka, Bangladesh. September 18, 2007

The government is likely to send two members of the high-powered advisory committee, formed to finalise the coal policy, to attend a SAARC technical conference on coal to be held in Kolkata on October 12. The energy division has recommended to the government that Professor Nurul Islam, director of the BUET’s Institute of Appropriate Technology, and Professor Badrul Imam of the Department of Geology of Dhaka University should attend the conference. ‘Both the experts have expressed interest in attending the one-day conference as it will help them to give more input, based on the other SAARC countries’ experience, to the proposed coal policy,’ said a source in the division.

The members of the 11-member advisory committee, headed by former BUET vice-chancellor Abdul Matin Patwari, are scheduled to visit three coal-fields on Friday before the committee scrutinises every paragraph of draft of the coal policy submitted by the energy division.

The committee has so far held more than five meetings and heard the recommendations of various experts and professional and human rights groups. Professor Nurul Islam, meanwhile, has been appointed the chairman of the board of governance of the SAARC Energy Centre that was set up in Islamabad in 2006. The chairman of the board is selected for three years from each member-country in alphabetical order.

The centre has taken steps to conduct a study on regional energy trade, which will be financed by the Asian Development Bank, while another programme will be launched on the experts’ capacity building. The primary objective for the establishment of the centre is to have a regional institution for the initiation, coordination and facilitation of SAARC energy programmes, said energy officials of Bangladesh.

Other objectives include strengthening the region's capability to address global and regional energy issues by enhancing the coordination of energy strategies of the SAARC states, and facilitating intra-regional trade in energy by the establishment of interconnecting arrangements for electricity and natural gas, such as the proposed power grid and trans-national gas pipelines.

The centre will also promote cooperation in energy efficiency and conservation as effective mechanisms for demand-side management, the development of new and renewable energy resources for sustainable energy development in the SAARC states over the long term.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Open-pit coal mining not viable

NewAge, Dhaka, Bangladesh. September 13, 2007

Bangladesh is undoubtedly heading towards a major energy crisis in the days to come. But with the reserve of coal, even if recovered even by open pit mining, will at best contribute a pond, if not a drop, in an ocean. So we must explore multiple options like undertaking massive search for oil, gas and coal, tapping wind energy in the coastal belt, generating small-scale hydro-electricity in the hilly terrains, solar energy, and coal extraction by underground mining only from the known deposits, writes Dr Aftab Alam Khan, Professor Aftab Alam Khan, Department of Geology, Dhaka University.

An open pit coal mine may contribute four, five, even ten times greater than an underground coal mine does in energy production, an example cited from Germany. However, the controversy lies with a different scenario that might have been overlooked by some who are advocating for open pit coal mining in Bangladesh. The first line of comparison between the two should be drawn based on the principal condition lies with the same level and standard. If the level and standard between the two are different than those of the comparisons, it is not likely to sustain. Bangladesh and Germany are two countries with marked differences in culture, socio-economy, physiography, geomorphic, hydrogeologic and overall geologic point of views.

The North Rhine Westfalia (NRW) coal mine areas in Germany do not possess any catchment area like Teesta fan in Bangladesh. Neither does it possess such thick groundwater bearing formation like Dupitila in Bangladesh overlying directly coal beds. Sand, clay and gravel layers overlying the coal bearing formation in NWR converge towards a valley not even 10km wide and eventually is directed along the valley gradient towards The Netherlands occupying very negligible land in NWR, Germany. The NE-SW geological cross section of NWR coal mine area clearly exhibits its subsurface geological condition which is markedly different from Bangladesh coal field region. While the coal field regions in Bangladesh are characterised by more porous and permeable thick groundwater bearing layer directly overlying coal bearing formation and diverge radially along multiple river valley systems occupying around 50 per cent of the valley covered region. In addition, around 30 per cent and more area of the Teesta fan will be affected by massive groundwater depletion. Both surface and subsurface gradients in the North Rhine Westfalia (NRW) coal zone are directed to only narrow linear zone along Rhine river valley. While, both the surface and subsurface gradients of Bangladesh coal field areas are directed radially along Sib-Barnai, Atrai and Little Jamuna river valley systems.

It is reported that the NRW mining area is pumping out 550 million cubic metres of groundwater annually where open pit mining is likely to start and very interestingly this mining area is not characterised by or linked to any such region like Teesta fan and thick Dupitila formation. Hence, it is apprehended that if an open pit mine is started in Bangladesh it would require dewatering few times higher than that of NWR open pit mine area. Barapukuria underground coal mine is pumping out around 15 million cubic meter of water annually from a water bearing formation at around 300m depth which is markedly sealed at the top by an impermeable shale/clay layer separating overlying highly porous and permeable Teesta fan sediments and Dupitila formation. Thus, the present dewatering at Barapukuria underground mine is being managed for the water discharging only from the coal bearing formation alone. An obvious question arises as to how much water shall be required to be pumped out when an open pit mine face along with the entire Teesta fan and Dupitila in coal field areas will be open?

An article/company brochure published by RWE Power AG (www.mining-technology.com) states quote ‘Rheinbraun has developed sophisticated dewatering programmes that can handle up to 1,200Mmm³/y of groundwater without affecting neighboring communities’ water supplies’. However, it did not mention actually how much of water is being managed by dewatering and from flooding in actual field development. The article has projected very successfully the positive sides of an open-pit coal mining in NRW, Germany but it has very candidly overlooked the article published in Natural Resources on March 21, 2007 by Steffen Winter (http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany) where it was written ‘Germany has little oil or natural gas, but it does have large reserves of another resource: lignite. However its extraction through open cast mining is highly controversial — and can lead to the disappearance of entire villages’. It further states that ‘the excavators used at the mining facilities have devastated an area equal to 182,000 soccer fields, wiping at least 244 villages and neighbourhoods off the map’. More interestingly it states that ‘Central German Brown Coal Mining Company (Mibrag) has been owned by US investors — Washington Group International and NRG Energy — since 1994 –– there’s no shortage of money, and the firm is used to dealing with public resistance. The company has been trying to access the coal beneath the town of Heuersdorf in Saxony since 1994, the citizens protested, but then the so-called “Heuersdorf Law” was passed by Saxony’s state parliament, stating that the village — which is 709 years old — has to be vacated by 2008, the dead buried in the cemetery will be moved to new graves and the church will be rebuilt elsewhere’.

Germany is a net energy importer, with its total energy consumption exceeding its production by a very large margin. Germany presently ranks as the world’s 5th greatest energy consumer, accounting for about 3.4% of the world’s annual energy consumption. Germany has consumed about 4 million gigawatt-hours of electricity in the year 2003 against only one third of its own production in comparison to Bangladesh’s approximately 50 thousand megawatt-hours of electricity. A comparison on other components is listed in the table. With such differences, how could an example of benefit out of open pit mining be brought to justify the same for Bangladesh?

Bangladesh is undoubtedly heading towards a major energy crisis in the days to come. But with the reserve of coal, even if recovered even by open pit mining, will at best contribute a pond, if not a drop, in an ocean. So we must explore multiple options like undertaking massive search for oil, gas and coal, tapping wind energy in the coastal belt, generating small-scale hydro-electricity in the hilly terrains, solar energy, and coal extraction by underground mining only from the known deposits. Import of gas from Shwe Gas Field on the Arakan coast in Myanmar might be another option to minimise immediate crisis.

Sunday, September 9, 2007

Phulbari, Asia Energy and Grassroots Revolt


Phulbari, Asia Energy and Grassroots Revolt, SEHD Report
www.sehd.org

In the last week of August 2006, an unbelieving nation watched, with increasing concern, tragedy unfold in a coal-rich area of Dinajpur. Popular protests against the Asia Energy Project had resulted in firing by the BDR on citizens, leaving at least three dead and more than two hundred injured. In this report Philip Gain looks at the issue and explains the background to the crisis.

The grassroots revolt in Phulbari against the open-cut mining plan of Asia Energy, a British company, seemed like an unstoppable inferno. The anger of the local people was real. They took to the streets of Phulbari town in thousands on 26 August 2006. It was an unprecedented scene. An estimated 50,000 farmers, laborers, members of ethnic communities, teachers, students, politicians—most of them from the mine area—assembled in the Phulbari town to tell the foreign company that it must vacate their land and sacred places. They would rather die than allow the company to open up their land for coal that would require relocation of a huge population.

The protesters had just sticks in their hands. The Santals (the largest ethnic community in North Bengal) joined with their drums, bows and arrows. The National Committee to Protect Oil, Gas, Mineral Resources, Power and Port organized the massive protest event. The protesters began their march towards the offices of Asia Energy at about 3:30 P.M. without understanding that the worst was waiting.

As the massive rally reached the Chhoto Jamuna river, they were stopped by barricades set by the security forces. While the main part of Phulbari town is located on the east of the river with a small bridge over it, the head office of Asia Energy and its warehouse are located on the other side. The barricades were set to stop the protesters from going near the company’s head office. The leaders of the national committee talked to the Upazila Nirbahi Officer (UNO), who according to Prof. Anu Muhammad, the member secretary of the committee, gave his word to move Asia Energy out of the town.

This was not the end of the day! As Prof. Anu Muhammad and other leaders of the national committee went back, some protesters crossed the river as reported by eyewitnesses. A rally also approached from the western side of the river. The protesters on the western side of the river suddenly came under massive gunfire from the BDR and teargas shells from the police. At least three people (the missing two are believed dead) were killed and more than two hundred were wounded. The bloodshed led to a seemingly unstoppable protest leading to a continued strike in Phulbari. The demand for expulsion of the company from Phulbari and also from the country became stronger. The protesters set the deadline for the foreign company’s exit at 11:00 A.M. on 28 August. Given that Asia Energy’s employees were still there, the angry protesters burnt the information center of Asia Energy and ransacked its laboratory (warehouse) that stored samples of coal extracted from 150 drilling sites. Finding no way out, the Asia Energy staff then sealed their main office and left Phulbari in a roundabout way, viz., through Dinajpur, under police escort. The people also ransacked and burnt the houses of a number of people identified to be accomplices of Asia Energy.

It was on the fourth day [August 30, 2006] of the continued strike that the Government, in a dramatic turn, submitted to the Phulbari protesters and agreed to meet all six of their demands. Foremost of the demands are to expel Asia Energy from four Upzilas including Phulbari and the country. The government also agreed not to opt for open-cut mining in four Upazilas including Phulbari and any other part of Bangladesh.

The agreement was reached in a meeting at Parbatipur Upazila, neighboring Phulbari and one of four Upazilas in the mine footprint. Rajshahi City Corporation Mayor Mr. Mizanur Rahman Minu signed the deal on behalf of the government while Prof. Anu Mohammed signed it on behalf of the National Committee to Protect Oil, Gas, Mineral Resources, Power and Port. In accordance with the agreement, the national committee representing the protesters ended the strike and other protest programs. The government conceded to compensate the families of those killed and pay the medical expenses of those wounded. A sum of Taka two lacs was sanctioned to each of the families of the 26 August killings and Taka nine lacs for the treatment of those injured and damages caused in the ransack of hotel, restaurant, houses, etc. The government also gave its word to drop cases filed against the protesters and reinforce inquiries into the killings of August 26 and the alleged hiding of corpses. The government was also to cease from harassing and filing any new cases against the protesters.

While the people became jubilant in Phulbari and quiet for the time being, full implementation of the agreement between the National Committee to Protect Oil, Gas, Mineral Resources, Power and Port and the government seems to be the hardest part of the episode. The initiative to strike a deal with the protesters is reported to be a matter handled solely by the prime minister’s office. The energy adviser and the concerned ministry reportedly know nothing officially about the government deal with the Phulbari protesters.

According to the agreement between the government and the national committee, the government was to terminate the contract with Asia Energy within one month from the date of signing it. However, according to Prof. Anu Muhammad the agreement has not been implemented to date. In the mean time, the company (Asia Energy PLC) has changed its name to Global Coal Management PLC (in the second week of January 2007) although the company’s Bangladesh subsidiary’s name would reportedly remain unchanged.

What has happened in Phulbari is tragic and it is important that all concerned honestly look into the factors that had led to this catastrophic situation.


The Project

An Australian company, BPH, started coal exploration in the Phulbari area. The Bangladesh government signed a contract with BPH through an open tender. In 1998, the contract was transferred to Asia Energy. Asia Energy, after estimating the coal reserve, submitted to the government a plan of operation. The government has already granted environment clearance to the company.

According to Asia Energy, 5,900 hectares or 59 sq. km. land area is required for the mine. The area covers more than a hundred villages of seven unions in four Upazilas—Phulbari, Birampur, Nawabganj and Parbatipur—and part of Phulbari Sadar Upazila, under Dinajpur district. Thousands of acres of cropland fall within its boundaries.

The area of Phulbari Thana Sadar that falls within the project area has brick-built houses, schools, colleges, tarmacked roads, railroads, business facilities and so forth. Outside the township lie vast crop fields, forest patches and plantations. Beneath the expanse of beautiful landscapes lies the 38m thick (on average) coal fossilised over 270 million years. According to Asia Energy the coal reserve in this mine is 572 million tons. The company believes, if explored, more coal will be traced south of the present mine.

Who Benefit and Who Lose?

Appointed by Asia Energy, GHD, an international organisation, prepared a report for the company that claims Bangladesh will receive benefits worth US$21 billion over the 30 years of the mine’s lifetime. Of this, US$7.8 billion will come as a direct benefit and US$ 13.7 billion, as indirect or multiplier benefits. The mine itself and the coal-fired plant for production of electricity will contribute one percent per annum to the GDP of the country.

How dependable is this estimate of Asia Energy? Economist Prof. Anu Muhammad, in an interview with Sangbad, a vernacular daily newspaper, contended: “This evaluation of the mine project is a kind of deception. It only shows how Bangladesh will benefit from the investment of Asia Energy and suppresses the extent of damage it would cause. This is actually a sham on Asia Energy’s part because it intends to cover up the questions about its activities that have already been raised.” The inhabitants of the mine area complain that people living in other parts of the country do not realize their plight, nor do they foresee the disaster the open pit mining is likely to cause to this region.

“We heard there is a coal deposit in this area. But the people engaged by Asia Energy did not let us know that the method for mining would be open cut, which necessitates eviction and destruction of our houses, schools, colleges and all other establishments in the mine footprint. All of us, irrespective of party affiliations, are against it,” said Md. Khurshid Alam Moti, leader of the Phulbari Raksha (protection) Committee. He is also the principal of Phulbari Women’s Degree College and chairman of Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) in Phulbari.

According to Asia Energy that is in contract with the Bangladesh government for exploration of coal, 40,000 people need to be relocated from the mine footprint. But the Phulbari Raksha Committee that is composed of people from all parties at the local level contends the company’s estimate. “We understand that about 150,000 people of the mine area will be directly affected and 200,000 to 250,000 will be affected indirectly,” said Moti.

Nima Banik, a lecturer at Phulbari Women’s Degree College says, “No matter wherever we are put, if we get evicted from our homes, we will lose our traditions, social organization and businesses. These losses are beyond compensation. Moreover, we do not trust Asia Energy. Its estimate is unfounded.”

M. Anwarul Islam, Asia Energy’s general manager (environment and community) disagreed and said, “We have always mentioned the idea of open pit. In Phulbari, there is no other option.”

According to the company all the damages will be compensated and the condition of the inhabitants of the mine area will be better than before. However, the aura of distrust and the demand of the locals is clear: “We do not want open pit mining.” From June 2005 the Phulbari Raksha Committee has been organising processions and meetings every Saturday in Phulbari in protest against it.

Asia Energy claims that Bangladesh has no risk in the Phulbari mine project. The company claims that Bangladesh will receive half of the total profit accrued from the mining operation. The profit includes 6 percent royalty, 45 percent corporate tax and 2.5 percent import duty. The other gains of Bangladesh as the company mentions will be “a new source of energy for the country, a new commodity for export, new industries, employment opportunities, regional development, poverty alleviation, growth of nascent industry, new rail and port infrastructure.”

Professor Anu Muhammad’s fear is: “It is Bangladesh where the coal has been found; and a foreign company will become its owner. There is no proper way to measure the actual benefit of Bangladesh and the price it would have to pay for it. What becomes clear is Bangladesh will have to buy its own coal from the company at an international price.”

Impacts on Environment

A serious concern of open pit mining is its environmental impacts. The method requires the mine area to be completely dewatered so that the hollow of the mine does not get immersed in water. Not an easy task. Large pumps are required to suck out underground water around the mine round-the-clock during the entire lifetime of the project. The impact on the already dry Barind Tract is obvious. Water level runs lower in the Barind Tract the during dry season and makes it difficult for the tubewells to draw water. When dewatering for the mining starts, the shallow and deep tubewells will not draw enough water for farmers in the larger area near the mine.

Asia Energy’s solution is to distribute the water pumped out among the farmers. It is an open question if the water distribution will be even-handed. The government and non-government organizations have been trying many options including tree plantation for many years now to prevent desertification in north Bengal. If dewatering in the mining area hastens the desertification process, pouring water above the ground remains a doubtful viable option for agricultural sustainability.

According to Asia Energy sources the average thickness of the coal layer in Phulbari is 38m. In order to reach the layer of coal, overburden between 150 and 250m needs to be removed, leaving a thousand-foot deep hollow. Once used up, the hollow will be filled with earth and a new area will be dug out. The area filled up does not become useful for many years. According to a high official in Asia Energy, topsoil will be removed and preserved once the mining operation begins in a particular block. Topsoil will be brought back and spread on the top of the area filled in. But no one can say when the land becomes cultivable again. The other question is: will the company fill the hollow with the same care as is done in developed countries? Non-compliance of existing laws is a common practice in Bangladesh.

At the final stage of the mining operation, about 30 years after the operation begins, Bangladesh will get a huge lake that according to the company will be filled up with fresh water providing a big source of water, fishery and recreation. But mining experts warn that the final hollow, after 30 years of digging and other activities, will contain toxic substances. It may not be realistic to envision this polluted lake becoming a source of fresh water.

Handling the other forms of environment pollution is also a challenge. There will be routine dynamite explosion inside the mine to break the rocks and the coal. Heavy machinery will be set up in and outside the mine. Heavy 240-ton trucks and trains will carry the coal causing noise pollution. Coal dust will be a major source of air pollution. If the enormous amount of polluted water generated from washing the coal is not properly treated before it is dumped into surrounding water bodies, it will kill fish and other forms of life. Further, the earth through such deep digging and many types of pollution will lose all its micro-organisms. Air pollution from burning coal to produce electricity is a big concern. Air polluting agents such as sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxide, volatile organic compounds (VOC), mercury, lead, cadmium, chromium, and arsenic will contaminate earth, water, plants and animals.

Eliminating pollutants is extremely difficult. Asia Energy expects to keep the pollution within a tolerable level. However, there is a fear that the company will not adopt adequate measures to mitigate pollution because these involve much effort and cash.

Transportation of the coal is another concern. In order to market, it will be carried to the deep seaport through the Sundarbans. New seaport and railroads need to be built for this. On the positive end, this will create employment and bring in revenue, but it also adversely affects the environment of the Sundarbans (the largest mangrove forest on earth). The noise and water pollution created by the Mongla Port has already become a threat to the animals, plants and other life forms in the mangrove forest. The added transportation over the 30 years of the mine’s lifetime will increase threats to the Sundarbans. The environmental and social impact assessment (EIA and SIA) of the Phulbari Coal Project has already been carried out and approved by the Department of Environment of Bangladesh government. Three hundred consultants from several international and national companies, some Bangladeshi environmental organizations and individuals have done the EIA and SIA. They have produced 2,600-page reports after 18 months of work. This is where many question if the EIA and SIA commissioned by the same company that will extract the coal have been impartial. Asia Energy claims it will do all that is needed for the protection of environment and social harmony.

Although the people of the mine area and their supporters stand against the open pit project, they are not against extraction of the coal in general. Their understanding is that the ownership of the coal and the fate of the affected people just cannot be handed down to a foreign company. They suggest waiting until the country develops its own mining expertise and technology. “We may give our consent when the country will be able to mine the coal resource with our own technology,” said Principal Moti. There are many others whose voices join Principal Moti’s.

Asia Energy had turned down the demand of the Phulbari people to wait until Bangladesh built its own expertise and mining technology. It says that by the time Bangladesh has its own mining expertise and resources, the fossil fuel may not be required any longer. The company claims that it is high time to extract the coal. Now the local communities have contested the company with their blood.

Looking Ahead

All that has happened in Phulbari—violence, expression of anger and mistrust of the local communities about Asia Energy—has shaken the whole nation. The whole world has also looked at Bangladesh with concern and curiosity. For now Phulbari has retuned to normal life. But the fear still persists. Application of the state security forces against the people has caused an uproar in their minds. They have sent a very strong message to the state agencies and the company that it is their land that contains 270 million year old coal. It is them who decide if the resource is to be shared in the best interest of the community and the nation. It is the state that must protect the land and the communities. It was certainly a fatal mistake to attempt to resolve a serious human problem with bullets and teargas. If the state of Bangladesh is really for the people, its functionaries must stay bowed before the people’s power and respect the commitments that they have made to their representatives. If that happens, it will be a step forward for providing political protection to those who need it most.

COMAPANIES AND INDIVIDUALS PROVIDING SPECIALIST INPUTS TO THE EIA

SMEC International Pty Ltd, Australia: Project management, social impact assessment, resettlement planning, environmental monitoring, surface water hydrology, hydraulic modelling, GIS, air quality, noise, rehabilitation, water quality, traffic, town planning, the environmental management plan, EIA/SIA reporting.

GHD Pty Ltd, Australia: Resource evaluation, geotechnics, hydrogeology, local and regional infrastructure and transport, data management, geophysics, river diversion studies.

Mine Consult Pty Ltd, Australia: Mine design and mine scheduling.

QCC Ltd, Australia: Coal quality, coal treatment plant.

Coffey Geosciences Pty Ltd: Water management, mine water balance.

Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS), Bangladesh: GIS database, surveying, field hydrology instrumentation and data collection.

Nature Conservation Management (NACOM), Bangladesh: Dry and wet season ecological database and biodiversity field assessments.

Bangladesh Atomic Energy Commission (BAEC): Airborne particulate matter sample analysis, quality assurance auditing, geophysical borehole logging.

Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS): Resettlement surveys.

Health Promotions Limited: Health impact assessment.

Institute of Water Modelling (IWM), Bangladesh: Regional surface water modeling.

The World Conservation Union (IUCN): Legislative and policy advice, peer review of biodiversity study.

Dr. M.K.Ahmed, Dhaka University: Arsenic in groundwater assessment.

Dr. N.Kamal & K.Z. Ashan, Independent University: Demographics.

Mr. Mannan, Independent University: Anthropology, ethnic minorities.

Professor M Hoque, Jahangirnagar University: Archaeology, historical sites.

Dr. Amin, Hazi Danesh Science & Technology University, Dinajpur: Soil science and agriculture.

Professor SMM Rahman, Dhaka University: Socio-economics.

Dr. Zaman, Canada: Resettlement.

Dr. Chris Johansen: Agriculture, land utilisation, rehabilitation.

Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (BUET): Water quality testing.

ALS Environmental Laboratories, Brisbane, Australia: Water quality testing.

International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh (ICDDR,B): Bacteriological and arsenic testing.

Source: Environmental Impact Assessment, Phulbari Coal Project, Asia Energy, June 2005

PHULBARI COAL PROJECT : SOME BASICS
[According to Asia Energy, 2006]

• Project Proponent: Asia Energy Corporation (Bangladesh) Pty Ltd. the Bangladesh subsidiary of UK based Asia Energy PLC.

• Product: Bituminous coal (high calorific value, low ash, low sulphur)—both thermal and metallurgical.

• Estimated Coal Deposit: 572 million tons some 150-250 meters beneath the surface.

• Co-Product: Clay, Sand, Gravel, Kaolin, Water.

• Total Coal Resource: 572 million tones (could be higher still with further drilling in the south).

• Export/Local consumption: Coal will be both exported and consumed domestically. Export will be mostly through Khulna and Akram Point in partnership with Bangladesh Railway and Mongla Port Authority.

• Project life: More than 30 years.

• Project timeframe: Dewatering is due to start in 2006, physical mine development in 2007 and first production of coal in 2008.

• Project area: 7 Unions and 1 Municipality in 4 Upazilas of Phulbari, Birampur, Nawabganj and Parbatipur in the district of Dinajpur.

• Total land area required for the Project: About 5,900 hectares over the life of the mine.